Friday, October 6, 2017

October 7th, 2017: American Horror Story - Roanoke

Today, I'm gonna do something unconventional that I haven't done in this blog yet: review an entire season of a TV show instead of a movie. The reason I'm doing this is because I just "accidentally" crushed an entire season of American Horror Story and wanted to talk about it, but I feel like no one watched the Roanoke season, so I bring the review here. With the Cult season in full swing right now, Roanoke is gonna get a little bump in viewership again because it just came to Netflix and I think that's a good thing.

AHS: Roanoke is the 6th installment of the popular horror series by Ryan Murphy and Brad Falchuk. The story and even some of the cast changes every season so that each season operates as a stand alone mystery. While the themes of most of the seasons before Roanoke were teased and leaked to generate excitement, this particular season was shrouded in mystery, which must have been on purpose to mirror the mystery of the lost colony of Roanoke. Told in a sort of confessional reality TV mock up, Roanoke's story centers on Matt and Shelby, a couple who purchases a home in North Carolina only to find themselves tormented by spirits and redneck neighbors and the eventual search for Matt's sister Lee's daughter, all set against the backdrop of the North Carolina rural woods and under the blood moon. Viewers will have to follow the threads of the mystery to find out if Lee will find her daughter in time before the power of the blood moon overwhelms her and to find out the true story behind the Roanoke mystery and the power word, "Croatoan".

I think the fact that I was able to finish this one season with relative ease is a testament to his strength. I am happy that I wasn't watching during the premiere because I might have been as let down as other fans with the revelation of the "My Roanoke Nightmare" reality TV theme of this season but after the first few clunky minutes of exposition, I found the lens enjoyable. The story and mystery is strong in this season, especially when it stands back to back with AHS: Hotel which I thought was quite a weak season, and the terror is visceral and real. I think this is the first AHS season to unsettle me during my dreams which is what I have been hoping for since the show started. As always, Kathy Bates shines through as perfectly as she does in any role. Without giving up too much, I also liked that part way through the show, some of the actors were able to switch up their characters or else do something besides just "confessional tapes" so you really get to see your favorite actors from earlier seasons shine. And another note that I think is important: they didn't build this season just on the hype of Lady Gaga being part of the cast. That was the nail in the coffin for hotel in my opinion, whereas Gaga shines here in a role that's strong but not in glaring focus like the Countess. Overall, the campy pay out of this season made it enjoyable to watch over a lazy day inside.

However, no season is without mistakes and Roanoke certainly had it's share of terrible garbage to wade through. First of all, I didn't mind the jump from "My Roanoke Nightmare" to "3 Days in Hell" but the shifting from one false television special to another really started to lose me by the final minutes of the last episode. I found it amusing at first but it seems like the first 8 episodes of the season were fleshed out well and the last two were thrown together to ultimately reach an ending. This seems to be a constant issue with American Horror Story anyway, but these episodes felt really patched together. I also wasn't a big fan of all the different stories trying to play out here, both with an addition of too many characters to throw as many old cast members into this one, as well as ham fisted attempts to connect to older seasons. For example, I was incredibly interested in Gaga's character as the woods witch because apparently she is the original supreme of the coven from the third season, but the show followed that path for maybe a minute and then abandoned it. Furthermore, after a point, I really couldn't find myself attached to a lot of the characters, so their deaths in the show didn't really take me by surprise and I often found myself rooting against some of them.

Still, with all that said, I really am glad I finally got to see it and I enjoyed the season far more than Hotel or Freakshow so I have high hopes for AHS: Cult. If you want to watch Roanoke, you can find it on Netflix streaming as well as Hulu so there are multiple ways to binge penultimate season up to this point.

Gore Factor: Gory!!!
Scare Factor: Genuinely Scary
Rating: 8.5 out of 10

No comments:

Post a Comment